What’s ‘time theft’ and why are some employers so labored up about it?

What’s ‘time theft’ and why are some employers so labored up about it?

It could be a brand new yr, however many employers are nonetheless counting on an outdated device for evaluating productiveness.

That might be the clock — in opposition to which a lot of labor is measured, regardless of ongoing modifications in how, the place and when work will get carried out.

Employers and workers can typically butt heads over what occurs on firm time, however in extreme instances, an worker might be accused of time theft. And this challenge is rising extra contentious as employers monitor what distant employees are doing outdoors of the confines of conventional places of work. 

“Time theft is arguably a fair greater challenge for employers presently than it has been earlier than,” stated Nadia Zaman, an employment lawyer with Rudner Legislation in Markham, Ont.

Not what you are paid to be doing

Time theft encompasses a broad vary of behaviours — something from taking longer-than-scheduled breaks or logging off early, to utilizing work hours to do family duties — all of which an employer would view as being opposite to what one ought to be doing whereas getting paid to work.

“Time theft is basically when the individual really ought to be working they usually’re not,” stated Janet Candido, a Toronto-based HR advisor. “They’re actively doing one thing else.”

A file photo, from June 2018, looking up at some office towers in Toronto's financial district.
Working life modified for thousands and thousands of Canadians in 2020, when the pandemic pressured organizations to ship folks house in a rush.  Exterior of the confines of conventional places of work, employers could now discover themselves monitoring how workers spend their paid time. (Tijana Martin/The Canadian Press)

Zaman, wanting by an employment-law lens, stated it is primarily “when an worker is paid for work that they haven’t carried out,” or for time wherein they weren’t really working.

Many individuals may discover themselves often responsible, particularly with the distractions of distant work. However the issue — and when it actually turns into time theft — is when it turns into ordinary.

Nita Chhinzer, an affiliate professor within the College of Guelph’s division of administration, stated organizations undergo a collection of steps when instances of alleged time theft are recognized. As soon as it is documented, that normally results in progressive self-discipline, she stated.

“It results in a verbal warning, adopted by a written warning, adopted by dismissal in some instances,” she stated.

However Chhinzer stated there are organizations that take a more durable line that “theft is theft,” and act decisively.

A headline-making case in Hamilton a decade in the past, for example, noticed the southwestern Ontario metropolis examine after which take disciplinary motion in opposition to dozens of municipal highway employees it suspected of infractions that included time theft.

There have been stories of highway employees spending as little as two hours a day on the job. Some employees had been fired, however most acquired their jobs again after arbitration.

An ongoing stress

Working life modified for thousands and thousands of Canadians in 2020, when the pandemic pressured organizations to ship folks house in a rush. That left employees and employers having to regulate to the brand new circumstances.

“It is extra of an issue with folks working remotely, actually,” stated Candido.

Zaman stated there’s not numerous case legislation involving time theft disputes and distant work to level to but. However the challenge of time theft goes again additional than that. The Canadian Authorized Data Institute web site (a database of authorized paperwork) has properly over 300 entries courting again to 1996 that point out the time period.

Some employers are putting in software program to watch the exercise of workers logged in at house. (Sebastian Leck/CBC)

“It is really been round for some time,” stated Candido, who recollects advising shoppers, previous to the pandemic, on addressing the difficulty of individuals watching movies on cellphones throughout their workday.

Information tales lately have revealed allegations of time theft being raised by quite a lot of employers — together with an accounting agency, eating places and municipal planning departments, and involving allegations starting from workers billing for time that they had not labored to folks utilizing their work time to conduct private errands. 

Zaman stated time theft is a broad challenge which may be raised in quite a lot of contexts and jobs.

“Usually we see it extra within the context of hourly workers due to the character of the work. However it doesn’t suggest that it will possibly’t occur for salaried workers,” she stated.

Why the clock retains ticking

For a lot of employers, the clock has lengthy been a mainstay of how they hold tabs on what’s getting carried out.

“Most employers do not know the best way to measure productiveness in another means,” stated Candido, the HR skilled, noting that stance has spurred extra of them to make use of software program to watch the exercise of workers who’re working at house.

Organizations are utilizing such instruments to find out if the one that has logged onto their pc is definitely doing work, she stated. Simply final week, The Canadian Press reported {that a} tribunal ordered a British Columbia accountant to pay her former employer greater than $2,600 after a monitoring software program confirmed she engaged in time theft whereas working from house.

The College of Guelph’s Chhinzer stated this strategy is rooted in “legacy considering” about jobs being constructed round a strict schedule and an outlined alternate of a sure amount of cash for a specific amount of time labored.

“That is how now we have thought of jobs for therefore lengthy,” stated Chhinzer, who just lately wrote in The Dialog Canada in regards to the flaws of such clock-focused considering.

It is also not the way in which that numerous data employees go about their work, she stated.

“If we are able to discover methods to be extra productive, then we should always nonetheless be compensated and rewarded to the identical degree for finishing the work, with out being penalized for our productiveness,” she stated.

Eroded belief

Paul Hutton, who works out of the Better Toronto space, is a director in a private-sector firm — a job that includes managing dozens of workers.

With a background in gross sales, he says he is lengthy been used to working in an atmosphere the place folks had been efficiently working outdoors an workplace.

WATCH | What are the perks of going again to work?

Work perks: What would convey you again to the workplace?

Dec. 2, 2022 | Some firms are pulling out all of the stops to convey folks again to the workplace: espresso bars with baristas, renovated workspaces, gyms and weekly catered lunches. Andrew Chang seems to be to seek out out which perks may fit and which of them could not.

Whereas he says he will get that some firms could have beforehand had issues about having folks working from house, it is clear to him that it will possibly work.

“You may obtain outcomes … you are able to do this remotely,” he stated, noting it includes placing belief in workers.

“Belief and honesty are essential,” stated Zaman, the employment lawyer, noting they could be much more so in conditions the place somebody works outdoors of an workplace.

From Candido’s perspective, the working world is seeing a broader erosion of the connection between employers and their workers “beginning with the pandemic and it is simply getting worse and worse.”


Learn More →